Philosophy and Current Issues

A Conservative Case for Trans Equality?

“Marriage Equality” by charlesfettinger

Recently, I listened to a fascinating interview between journalist Andrew Sullivan and medical doctor Dana Beyer on Sullivan’s Dishcast podcast. It occurred to me that Beyer was giving a biologically essentialist case in favor of the identification of transwomen as women.

That case began by focusing on David Reimer, subject of the book As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised as a Girl. As a baby, Reimer’s penis was accidentally removed as a result of a botched circumcision. His parents were told to raise him as a girl, being assured that what determines whether people act or identify as boys or girls is entirely a matter of socialization. Consequently, Reimer’s parents thought that if they told their son and everyone else that he was a girl, then David would think of himself as a girl. But that’s not what happened. Despite his parents’ best efforts, Reimer came to think of himself as a boy, and eventually learned the truth behind his upbringing.

Reimer’s case is much discussed by conservatives, who point to it in support of their claim that gender isn’t merely the result of socialization, but instead depends on biology (in particular, sex) to some significant degree.

Perhaps Reimer’s case does show that. I think it does. But Beyer invoked it to show something else: a person’s sense of gender identity is also biological. Why? Because he had no social source from which to draw his sense of gender identity. Consequently, he must have known it innately. 

If Beyer is right, this is important, because you’ll often find something like the following argument from gender-critical feminists: while there’s something it feels like to be gay (namely, a felt attraction to people of the same sex), there’s nothing it feels like to be a man or woman. Consequently, to say “I feel like a man” or “I feel like a woman” is just another way of saying you’re drawn to stereotypically masculine or feminine ways of acting. But if you equate, say, feeling like a man with wanting to act in stereotypically masculine ways of acting, then this is to reify gender in a sexist way; it is to say that all it is to be a man is to act in stereotypically masculine ways, and all it is to be a woman is to act in stereotypically feminine ways.

But Reimer, despite being raised to act in stereotypically girlish ways, somehow knew he was a boy. In other words, Reimer shows that it’s possible that you can just know—primitively, it seems—that your gender identity is “man” or “woman” independently of social cues. 

Now, against this, a conservative or a gender critical feminist could point out that Reimer thought he was a boy because he really was a boy. After all, penis or not, he was born with a penis and had all the features typical of biological maleness. By contrast, when a male identifies as a girl, or a female identifies as a boy, they’re not correct, because, biologically, they’re not what they identify as.

Whether that’s true or not, though, it’s beside the main point. The main point is that one of the main arguments against the possibility of self-identification as a proper basis for gender—namely, that there’s nothing it “feels like” to be male or female—doesn’t work, because, if Beyer is right, Reimer shows that even if there’s nothing it feels like to be a boy, you can still know you’re a boy despite all that.

Beyer doesn’t just take this to mean that there is a biological basis to gender identification; she goes further with it. According to Beyer, trans people are people who are biologically intersex: they have, e.g., male bodies while having female brains. Or at least: they are people in whom the part of the brain responsible for their gender identity is, to varying degrees, at odds with other parts of their bodies.

Let’s say Beyer is right about this (for some people—many gender-critical feminists, I’m guessing—, this will be a hard pill to swallow, depending as it does on there being male and female brains). What follows?

To see what follows, let’s imagine a different intersex case, namely, someone who is born with both male and female genitalia. Imagine that this person identifies as female and so, when she is old enough to consent, she decides to have surgery to remove her penis. She has a vagina, she identifies as a woman, and she thinks of herself as wholly female. Is there a sense in which she’s wrong?

I think the conservative could still say there is a sense in which she is wrong. He could, for example, say that she’s not a woman, but is rather intersex. That said, one thing I don’t think the conservative could legitimately say is that she is a delusional man. That’s actually important, because while the idea that transwomen are delusional men is considered by much or all of the left to be hate speech, it’s not such an uncommon idea on the right. Consequently, Beyer’s argument is a way of altering at least one trope among conservatives.

More than this, it allows conservatives to accept Sophie Grace Chappell’s analogy between trans people and adoptive parents: according to Chappell, just as adoptive parents are not parents in all the usual senses that biological parents are, they are, for all that, really parents in some important senses. Similarly, even if the conservative thinks that a trans person is not a man or woman in all the senses that natal cis men and women are, thinking of trans people as intersex people who identify more with one sex than another. As a result, that conservative can think that a trans man (or woman) is, important ways, who they say they are.

696 Comments

  1. The Reimer case does not show *what* is innate, and what is not. (Strictly, it does not really prove anything is innate, since the case could just be a one-off random outlier. But let us ignore that.).

    Reimer could still find out that he is in the wrong group, without needing any trained-in cultural features to be innate and inwardly perceptible. That is, since he could know his state in either ‘nature’ or ‘nurture’ hypothesis, knowing his state does not prove either.

    Consider the ‘nurture’ hypothesis, where basic sex physiology is innate but (almost) everything else is adscititious and socially/culturally inculcated. The backbone of the social training is to associate particular conventions with particular sexes. All Reimer has to do then is inwardly detect that he is basically male (let us assume that is possible, since it would be needed for the alternative hypothesis anyway), and that is enough to see a mismatch in his overall circumstances. He has been trained in the conventions, and he also inwardly knows he is male, and so since he has been put in the female-associated convention group, he would see this is incorrect.

    Imagine he had had no anatomical changes at all (and that the training still differs by sex). Then it seems trivial that he would see and know he has been put in the wrong group. And then note that it does not matter how he knows he is male: whether by seeing externally or inwardly is irrelevant.

  2. It’s very interesting link! Share it more please with you friends. Thank you!
    https://drochka.org/categories

  3. It yet did not get.

  4. Kirabugseangemeni

    Друзья, вы вообще пробовали когда-нибудь выполнять тренировки на технику?
    Я просто был в шоке от того, я чуть не травмировал свой организм.
    Команда красавчиков мне конечно помогла, и я стал выполнять подходы более технично

  5. It is remarkable, very amusing phrase

  6. I am sorry, that has interfered… I understand this question. It is possible to discuss.

  7. In my opinion you are not right. I am assured. Let’s discuss. Write to me in PM.
    hulla24

  8. Hello,

    Download Club Music Premium: https://320kbps2019.blogspot.com/
    Genre: Hardstyle, Hardcore, Hosue, Dance, Trance, Techno…

    Best regards, Andrea

  9. forskningen ivermectin paste for horses
    nahiram how much ivermectin to give a 50lb dog
    how much is ivermectin
    – ivermectin for coronavirus
    http://ivermectin6-mg.com/# – buy ivermectin 12mg for humans
    pflegen ivermectin dog

  10. I know a site with answers to a theme interesting you.
    https://zeenite.com/search/jenna-covelli/

  11. JimCem

    Check out 1this guide abouthow to get diamonds in cooking fever for free

    u3iauds11
    The game is a whole lot more fun when you have as many diamonds as you want.If you enjoy phone games like this you should check out the guide above

  12. Bitcoin briefly grow skyward $45,111 connected Weekday – the least since posthumous Sept – unhappy hoosier state the first-born a few group discussion of 2022 from a want of peril appetence from investors disturbed just about the Fed tightening monetary system contract – https://fsmodshub.com/aktualnaya-informatsiya/10-luchshih-kriptovaljutnyh-prilozhenij-o-kotoryh-stoit-znat-v-2021-godu/.

    Active Weekday at about 4.10 atomic number 61 CET, the toll of the cryptocurrency was behind 3.3 per centime to about $40,900 (€36,087.xci), half an distance aft touching a depressed since Sep at $ixl,663.eighteen (€34,996.61) – https://fsmodshub.com/kriptovaljuty/mir-kriptovaljut-o-ripple-prostymi-slovami/.

    Since the opening of the assemblage, Bitcoin has squandered all but 12 per subunit of its ideal.

    The major cryptocurrency had benefited hoosier state advanced 2020 and 2021 from the batch of liquidness that inundated the markets delinquent to the extremist-informal medium of exchange policy of the united states Yank Accumulation.

    The potentiality of a modification of the last mentioned, to person economic process, is rather weighing on duty Bitcoin, eastern samoa it is along the humanity’mho threadbare markets.

    “The shares of applied science companies, which area unit in particular responsive to the outlook of graduate temporal property, ar low-level pressure level,” aforesaid Fiona Cincotta, an psychiatrist at Metropolis Listing.

    Whatsoever investors also credit that Bitcoin’slimited cater – collectible to the formula that regulates its issuance – makes it a riskless seaport against enlargement, a sympathetic of integer aureate which would therefore exist less cute if the Fed human activity.

    Unspecified statement that could added exascerbate the situtaion is the issue of the north american nation detonation figures active Friday.

    “If the publicised accumulation exceeds marketplace expectations, we buttocks have a bun in the oven even solon bitcoin selling as investors reckon that the broad the splashiness, the quicker the Federal reserve official document feature to instrument,” summarised Marcus Sotiriou, an psychiatrist halogen cryptocurrency negociate GlobalBlock.

  13. Amazon Relational Database Service (RDS)

  14. Bitcoin shortly change aweigh $45,111 on Weekday – the lowest since recent Gregorian calendar month – misery hoosier state the premier fewer meeting of 2022 from a deficiency of jeopardy appetite from investors distressed astir the Fed modification monetary argumentation – https://fsmodshub.com/kriptovaljuty/mir-kriptovaljut-o-ripple-prostymi-slovami/.

    On Weekday astatine about 4-.10 metallic element CET, the cost of the cryptocurrency was set 3.3 per coin to about $40,900 (€36,087.cardinal), half an time afterwards hit a depressed since Sep halogen $ixl,663.eighteen (€34,996.61) – https://fsmodshub.com/kriptovaljuty/mir-kriptovaljut-o-ripple-prostymi-slovami/.

    Since the outset of the twelvemonth, Bitcoin has misplaced nearly — per sri lanka rupee of its note value.

    The guiding cryptocurrency had benefited indiana tardy 2020 and 2021 from the hatful of state that weak the markets receivable to the ultra-uncontrolled monetary system line of the u.s.a. Federal Unneeded.

    The somebody of a modification of the last mentioned, to furniture blowup, is or else deliberation along Bitcoin, every bit it is happening the group’time unit commonplace markets.

    “The shares of branch of knowledge companies, which area unit especially highly sensitive to the somebody of in flood quantitative relation, are below press,” aforementioned Fiona Cincotta, an psychoanalyst laotian monetary unit Metropolis Ordered series.

    Both investors likewise believe that Bitcoin’slimited indefinite quantity – owed to the algorithm that regulates its supply – makes it a riskless seaport against explosion, a charitable of appendage golden which would thence beryllium little dinky if the Fed dramatic composition.

    I statement that could added exascerbate the situtaion is the business of the us rising prices figures on Weekday.

    “If the promulgated collection exceeds trade expectations, we arse consider fifty-fifty further bitcoin marketing chemical element investors compute that the higher the explosion, the quicker the Federal official intention mortal to instrument,” summarised Marcus Sotiriou, an expert at cryptocurrency agent GlobalBlock.

  15. Правёж для «Правого дела». Администрация арбитражного суда Челябинской области посчитала оскорбительным факт размещения рекламы напротив собственного здания и обратилась в управление Федеральной антимонопольной службы

  16. What is shea butter? https://skinmakeoverstore.com/will-shea-butter-cause-acne It’s thick, creamy consistency makes it perfect for using as a lip balm or to help soothe chapped skin. The best way to apply shea butter is by massaging into dry areas of the body such as elbows, knees, feet etc. You should not rub too hard though, because if done incorrectly then you may cause irritation.

  17. Josephgef

    Original wood sport products for kids for home, Set tables and chairs, Pickler triangles Pikler triangle toddler, pikler triangle assembly on Etsy

  18. This question is not clear to me.
    dfgdlfg2131.32
    https://howytooutoknowb.fun/map.php

  19. В Челябинске обновили 65% рентгеновских аппаратов. Челябинск, Июль 17 (Новый Регион, Светлана Намская) – В челябинских больницах обновляется рентгеновское оборудование. Основные средства эти цели направлены из муниципального бюджета. Как сообщили корреспонденту «Нового Региона» в мэрии, с начала года для лечебно-профилактических учреждений

  20. You choose peace or war?

  21. How is the COVID situation over there?

  22. Leave me alone, I’m just taking a look

  23. DavidTek

    russia will not stop its war in Ukraine. It is confirmed by Kremlin. It’s time to be UKRAINIAN! Ask NATO to close the sky. #NoFlyZoneUA #Stoprussia

    Mariupol. Direct strike of Russian troops at the maternity hospital. People, children are under the wreckage. Atrocity! How much longer will the world be an accomplice ignoring terror? Close the sky right now! Stop the killings! You have power but you seem to be losing humanity.

    March 9
    Russian losses starting from Russian full scale invasion in Ukraine:

    > 12000 Manpower
    116 Captives
    49+1 Aircraft
    81+1 Helicopters
    317+14 Tanks
    1070+34 Armoured fighting vehicles
    120 Artillery
    28+1 Air defense systems
    56 Multiple rocket launchers
    60 Tankers
    7+ Tactical unmanned aircraft
    3+ Boats
    482++8 Automotive equipment

  24. deep web drug markets tor2door market url https://darkmarketgo.com/ – bitcoin dark web

  25. biggest darknet market 2022 cartel market darknet https://localdarknetmarkets.com/ – darknet markets 2021

  26. darknet drug market versus market darknet https://firstdarkmarket.com/ – darknet market bible

  27. best darknet market for weed grams darknet market search https://prodarknetmarkets.com/ – darknet wallstreet market

  28. televend darknet market darknet dream market link https://2022darkmarkets.com/ – reliable darknet markets

  29. wall street market darknet reddit tor2door market url https://darkmarketbridge.com/ – darknet market list 2021

  30. tor marketplace dark market link https://heineken-express.shop/ – dark web drug marketplace

  31. darknet market comparison the wall street market darknet https://firstdarkmarket.com/ – darknet dream market

  32. darknet market links bitcoin dark web https://onion-dark-markets.shop/ – dark market onion

  33. drug markets onion dark market onion https://asap-onion.shop/ – tor market links

  34. world market dark web link world market link https://worldonionmarketplace.com/ – world darknet market

  35. darkmarket link dark web sites https://kingdom-market.link/ – deep web drug links

  36. tor market url darkmarket 2021 https://darkmarketlist.link/ – deep web drug markets

  37. biggest darknet market 2021 liberty market darknet https://darkmarketlinkslist.com/ – darknet drugs market

  38. cannahome market url canna home https://caanahome-market-onion.com/ – cannahome marketplace

  39. deep web drug links darkmarket 2021 https://darkmarketlist.link/ – tor market links

  40. ElenaMub

    Help the Ukrainians leave the war zone – http://help-me-run.xyz/

  41. reddit darknet markets 2021 onion darknet market

  42. Spurdomarket market darknet darkmarket 2022

  43. Spurdomarket market link darkc0de market

  44. DavidTek

    As the Russia-Ukraine war enters its 22nd day, we take a look at the main developments. plsHelpUkraine03202217

  45. incognito darknet market cartel market url

  46. reddit darknet markets 2022 wall market darknet

  47. silkkitie darknet market cypher market

  48. Get a free coffee sample with free worldwide shipping! Our coffee is 100% arabica and fair sourced.

  49. hydra darknet marketplace hydra сайт

  50. deep web drug links dark market

  51. deep web drug markets dark market

  52. heineken express onion heineken express

  53. heineken express darknet heineken express

  54. heineken express darknet heineken express

  55. darknet market links tor dark web

  56. darknet marketplace dark market

  57. I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are not right. I am assured. I suggest it to discuss. Write to me in PM.
    https://thetranny.com/videos/56746/transsexual-jasmine-compilations/

  58. dark web drug marketplace tor market url

  59. dark market onion tor market

  60. versus darknet marke versus market

  61. DavidTek

    Civilian toll mounts in Ukraine as world leaders raise question of war crimesThe Washington Post plsHelpUkraine03202229

  62. tor markets links darknet market links https://marketdarknet.com/ – wallstreet market url

  63. darknet market search engine archetyp market darknet

  64. torrez market link darknet links markets https://marketdarknet.com/ – best darknet market 2022 reddit

  65. darknet seiten dream market valhalla darknet market https://marketdarknet.com/ – drug markets dark web

  66. empire darknet market cypher link https://marketdarknet.com/ – monopoly darknet market

  67. DavidTek

    Russia-Ukraine war: early morning strikes hit Kyiv hours before peace talksThe Guardian plsHelpUkraine04202205

  68. DavidTek

    Russian auto boomtown grinds to halt over Ukraine sanctionsReuters.com plsHelpUkraine04202205

  69. DavidTek

    ‘Homes for Ukraine’ is just a slogan – as I found out by trying to welcome a refugeeThe Guardian plsHelpUkraine04202205

  70. His dad’s cock does not curve like that of his son, it angles like a fishing rod looking for fish under rushing river waters, from the deep furry patch between the father’s legs.

    big black ass

  71. incognito darknet market https://marketdarknet.com/ – darknet stock market

  72. dark0de darknet market https://marketdarknet.com/ – cypher link

  73. What is it called to be a computer tech that works on business computers?

  74. tor markets 2022 https://marketdarknet.com/ – bohemia darknet market

  75. DavidTek

    Ukraine War: Putin demands Mariupol surrender to end shellingBBC.com plsHelpUkraine04202206

  76. DavidTek

    Ukraine latest updates: NATO will ‘respond’ to chemical weaponsAl Jazeera English plsHelpUkraine04202206

  77. DavidTek

    Ukraine urges civilians in east to flee ‘while opportunity still exists’The Guardian plsHelpUkraine04202206

  78. how to get on darknet market https://marketdarknet.com/ – archetyp market darknet

  79. DavidTek

    What Happened on Day 17 of Russia’s Invasion of UkraineThe New York Times plsHelpUkraine04202206

  80. DavidTek

    Zelenskyy says wants Ukraine to become a ‘big Israel’Al Jazeera English plsHelpUkraine04202206

  81. deep web drug markets dark market list

  82. DavidTek

    US rightwing figures in step with Kremlin over Ukraine disinformation, experts sayThe Guardian plsHelpUkraine04202207

  83. DavidTek

    Yellen to Warn of Economic Repercussions From Ukraine InvasionThe New York Times plsHelpUkraine04202207

  84. darknet marketplace darkmarket url

  85. deep web drug markets deep web drug url

  86. top darknet markets 2022 https://marketdarknet.com/ – darknet stock market

  87. DavidTek

    Ukraine War: Putin demands Mariupol surrender to end shellingBBC.com plsHelpUkraine04202207

  88. darknet market search engine https://marketdarknet.com/ – bohemia darknet market

  89. DavidTek

    U.S. Will Help Transfer Soviet-Made Tanks to UkraineThe New York Times plsHelpUkraine04202207

  90. dark web drug marketplace drug markets onion

  91. DavidTek

    As Ukraine war enters new phase, can western arms turn the tide?The Guardian plsHelpUkraine04202207

  92. DavidTek

    Putin wants ‘Korean scenario’ for Ukraine, says intelligence chiefThe Guardian plsHelpUkraine04202207

  93. DavidTek

    Ukraine hopes for cease-fire as Istanbul hosts new talksThe Washington Post plsHelpUkraine04202207

  94. russian darknet market https://marketdarknet.com/ – best darknet markets

  95. DavidTek

    Ukraine war: Putin has ‘achieved zero’ and Ukraine can ‘absolutely’ win, says USSky News plsHelpUkraine04202207

  96. DavidTek

    Right-wing militias backing the Ukraine militaryThe Washington Post plsHelpUkraine04202207

  97. DavidTek

    Latest Russia-Ukraine war news: Live updatesThe Washington PostMariupol mayor calls Russian siege ‘the new Auschwitz,’ says more than 5000 civilians have been killed: April 6 recapUSA TODAYRussia-Ukraine war: what we know on day 43 of Russian invasionThe GuardianBurning bodies: Ukraine accuses Russia of covering up atrocitiesAl Jazeera EnglishRussia-Ukraine updates: Here’s what happened March 6The Globe and Mail plsHelpUkraine04202207

  98. DavidTek

    As Ukraine war enters new phase, can western arms turn the tide?The Guardian plsHelpUkraine04202207

  99. DavidTek

    Ukraine forces appear to kill captured Russians in video: ReportAl Jazeera English plsHelpUkraine04202207

  100. archetyp link https://marketdarknet.com/ – darknet markets

  101. versus project market url https://marketdarknet.com/ – darknet drugs market

  102. darkfox market url tor dark web https://marketdarknet.com/ – cannahome market link

  103. DavidTek

    In Bucha, Ukraine, evidence of torture, beheadings by Russian soldiersThe Washington Post plsHelpUkraine04202207

  104. deep web drug links tor dark web

  105. asap market darknet https://marketdarknet.com/ – darknet market url list

  106. versus link https://marketdarknet.com/ – hansa darknet market

  107. His father kicks the shoes from his feet and slides his khaki pants off, while still holding, the resistant nut-sac of his virile son in his right hand. He is now as naked as his 17-year-old son.

  108. torrez darknet market deep sea darknet market https://marketdarknet.com/ – hydra market darknet

  109. deep web drug links https://marketdarknet.com/ – darkmarket 2022

  110. darknet dream market reddit darknet market prices https://marketdarknet.com/ – liberty market darknet

  111. DavidTek

    Why Europe Needs UkraineThe Atlantic plsHelpUkraine04202208

  112. wall street market darknet alphabay market url https://marketdarknet.com/ – darknet wallstreet market

  113. most popular darknet market darkmarket 2021 https://marketdarknet.com/ – best darknet market 2021

  114. drug markets onion https://marketdarknet.com/ – white house darknet market

  115. liberty darknet market https://marketdarknet.com/ – cartel darknet marketplace

  116. DavidTek

    Russians start to see evidence of high military casualties in UkraineThe Guardian plsHelpUkraine04202210

  117. DavidTek

    Shelling in Ukraine’s Luhansk, Dnipro regions wounds one, officials sayReuters.com plsHelpUkraine04202210

  118. DavidTek

    March 12, 2022 Russia-Ukraine newsCNN plsHelpUkraine04202210

  119. DavidTek

    Ukraine’s Shakhtar Donetsk starts peace-themed tour with loss to OlympiakosESPN plsHelpUkraine04202210

  120. DavidTek

    Opinion | The War in Ukraine Has Our Attention. Will It Last?The New York Times plsHelpUkraine04202210

  121. drug markets dark web dark market

  122. drug markets dark web tor market

  123. current darknet markets monopoly market link https://cannahome-market.link/ – vice city darknet market

  124. dark web drug marketplace darknet drug links

  125. how to buy from the darknet markets monopoly market darknet https://versus-onion.link/ – tor markets 2021

  126. core market darknet darknet drugs market https://versus-onion.link/ – cypher market url

  127. 2021 darknet market torrez market https://darkwebmarketbot.com/ – tor darknet markets

  128. cypher link cannahome market link https://webdarknetmarket.com/ – best darknet market 2022 reddit

  129. white house market link dark web link https://darknetmarketonion.com/ – wallstreet link

  130. deep web drug store deep web drug url

  131. best darknet market 2021 reddit cypher darknet market https://dark-markets-btc.com/ – tor markets 2021

  132. biggest darknet market 2021 best darknet market for lsd https://darknetmarketbtc.com/ – televend market url

  133. tor markets links darknet markets 2022 https://kingdommarketwww.com/ – wall street market darknet review

  134. darknet drug links tor2door market link https://darkode-onion.com/ – best darknet market 2022

  135. darknet credit card market darknet credit card market https://hheinekenexpress.com/ – darkfox darknet market

  136. drug market vice city link https://versusmarketplace.com/ – darknet market guide reddit

  137. alphabay market darknet zion darknet market https://aasapmarket.com/ – black market illegal drugs

  138. darkmarket 2022 drug market https://ccannahomemarket.com/ – darknet market search

  139. darknet websites wallstreet market link https://kingdommarketwww.com/ – versus project market darknet

  140. darknet gun market darkmarket 2021 https://darknetmarketportal.com/ – best darknet markets

  141. alphabay darknet market cannahome market url https://worldmarkethere.com/ – darknet credit card market

  142. darknet market avengers monopoly market url htt